Can a financial advisor help couples who disagree about money?

Quick Summary
You and your spouse grew up in different houses and picked up different stories about what money means. That doesn’t go away because you share a checking account.
Money sits at the top of the list of marriage disagreements, and it starts with something specific. The budget, a major purchase, whether to pay for college.
Underneath those are the real questions. Whose money is it? What’s our money for? Do I trust you?
Talking more doesn’t automatically fix it. Couples who do well have a framework they both agree to follow.
The hardest part is forgiving each other’s money mistakes.
You married someone who grew up in a different house than you did. They watched their parents handle money a certain way, they picked up a set of values about it, and they carry a story about what money means.
So do you!
Then, the two of you tried, to varying degrees, to combine your finances and make decisions. Often, couples stumble into a pattern for their finances based on who cared more and who had time. The range of how couples have their money set up and how they make decisions varies widely.
These ideas highlight just how important it is to get who you marry right. It’s probably the most important financial decision you’ll ever make.
That depends on the type of financial advisor you hire and whether they have that skill set. Some do; some don’t.
My name is Michael Hollis, and I help couples in Aurora, IL, Chicagoland, and virtually across the US remove money as a source of tension.
Why do couples disagree about money?
Because you're two different people.
You come from different upbringings, you hold different values, and you each carry a different story, often subconsciously, about what money means. We call that your Money Script, and none of that goes away because you share a last name or a checking account.
It leads to money being at the top of the list of marriage disagreements.
The CFP Board describes the dynamics in their own recent report. This fall, they surveyed 820 Americans who are married or living with a partner, and the results suggest these relationship forces are close to universal.
In it, one in three said money is the number one source of stress in their relationship right now. Two in three put it in their top three, ahead of health, work, parenting, and intimacy. Nearly half of them said money is the most uncomfortable subject they discuss with their spouse.
What money issues do couples disagree about?
In my experience, the disagreement starts with a specific situation:
The monthly budget
A major purchase
Whether to take on debt
How much to save/invest
A job change
New business venture
Whether to pay for kids’ college
The major purchase one is specifically addressed in the CFP Board survey. More than seven in ten people say they consult their spouse before a big purchase. But nobody agrees on what counts as big.
Nineteen percent check in on anything over $100. A third draw the line somewhere between $100 and $499. Twenty percent say nothing until it reaches $500. Thirteen percent have no set amount at all. Have you decided on a specific number?
Two people can believe they're not doing anything wrong but still cause a ruckus because they aren’t on the same page with each other.
But is it really about the money?
What is money tension really about?
Even though disagreements start with something like these situations, underlying them are foundational questions that a couple has to answer.
Whose money is it?
What’s our shared financial vision?
Do I trust you?
And you can’t answer these without intentional time together and a lot of it.
Do couples hide financial decisions from each other?
Absolutely they do.
And I don’t get that just from survey results. That’s my experience working with couples. I generally encourage couples to lay all the cards on the table. If you’re considering marriage, especially so.
According to the CFP Board survey, most people said they disclosed some or all of their financial picture at the start of the relationship. But, five percent said they're still keeping significant parts of it to themselves. Two in five people said they made a major financial decision in the last twelve months without telling their partner, and almost a quarter of them did it more than once.
Does talking more about our finances fix it?
It can, but more talk doesn't automatically fix things either. Only 45% of survey respondents said their most recent difficult money conversation ended in a resolution. Another third said they partly worked it out and are still working on it. The remaining 22% either stopped trying or got nowhere.
That’s part of what got me thinking about writing this article.
Couples are having these conversations, but for a lot of them, they are still stuck. Sometimes you need an objective third party like a marriage counselor. Sometimes you need a shared set of financial rules you agree to follow.
Maybe both.
How do couples make money decisions together?
Before I lay out a framework that I think leads to couples making successful money decisions, I want to make one thing clear. Deciding together isn't the same as asking each other for permission, like kids asking their parents for an allowance. Yuck! If it feels like that, it’s not a money problem; it’s a relationship one.
Here’s a framework for couples to make money decisions together.
Stop treating each other as opponents. Avoid finger-pointing. You are on the same team.
Listen more than you talk. Be slow to speak, slow to anger, and quick to listen.
Build a shared vision for what the money is actually for.
Meet regularly. You're not going to agree overnight, and this is a habit you build over years.
Think ours, not mine.
Give each other access to everything.
When you reach a decision, commit to it. Spit-shake, pinky-swear.
If you’re looking for a tool that can flesh this out, download my Zero-based Budget Guide. It’s a free resource that explains the zero-based budgeting concept and provides practical guidance for how to implement everything I’m talking about.
Zero-based budgeting has the potential to transform your finances and your marriage.
What’s the hardest money issue to overcome?
Forgiving each other’s money mistakes.
When trust has been repeatedly broken, it takes time and new behaviors repeated over and over and over to trust again.
But there’s no question that forgiveness is the key that unlocks the healing.
Can a financial advisor help couples who disagree about money?
While getting to know clients and asking deeper money questions, I've had couples ask, “Is this a therapy session?”
To which I say “No” and chuckle a little.
I'm not a marriage counselor. If the two of you don't trust each other, or if this is strictly a relationship problem, a financial plan won't repair that. You should talk to someone who specializes in counseling.
But I do listen intently to what each of my clients is really saying, and I intentionally give space to one of them if the other is dominating the conversation. I also use reflections and other statements to help each person crystallize their thoughts. It also gets them hearing one another. That can seem like therapy, but it’s really me working to understand each person’s mindset, so I can figure out the roadblocks to implementing the financial plan.
I also get clients to look at real numbers while we are meeting together, so they're discussing facts and not just feelings. Awareness of the situation is powerful.
If you and your spouse keep having the same money conversation and get nowhere, I’d like the opportunity to join the discussion. Schedule an intro call.
Michael Hollis, CFP® is a flat fee financial advisor and the owner of TapestryFP. This article first appeared on the TapestryFP website and is republished on Flat Fee Advisors with permission.
